Que est-ce que c'est, le cinéma?
Ok Oh Grudge Match: Michael Mann vs. Quentin Tarantino or Inglorious Basterds v. Public EnemiesI desperately want to write a review of these movies. Desperately. I'd start by ruminating on the odd magical crock pot that is filmmaking. I'd say something about style. I'd follow it up with some
this is like that sort of statement. I'd make some disparaging remarks instantly retraced via faint praise. I'd finish up with a one-liner. But it snowed this weekend. And I bought a Christmas tree. My son picked it out. He walked down the row of Christmas trees, not really inspecting thoroughly, then stopped, pointed at the tree he wanted and that was that. We bought the tree for thirty five dollars, strapped it to the top of the car with one long piece of white, thin twine, and I carried it up three flights of stairs. We papier-mâché'd little balloons for ornaments. Actually, Wifey papier-mâché'd as I proved a disaster at it so I put the lights on the tree. Later, when we realized I didn't buy enough lights (Wifey swears she thought at the time I needed to buy three boxes) I went out again into the slush and snow and cold to get more. Before I left, I set Sonny up in front of the You Tube to watch his first Muppet Christmas Special. When I got back, we ate grilled cheese sandwiches. In between and around and during all this, we watched the two films in question. At times I had to stop the videos due to violence in proximity to youth, or to put said youth in a bath. But, all in all, we did watch the films, in the end. Well, I did. During one of the films, Wifey decided she needed to do a little Pilates workout instead. This is all to say that, true to form, whatever review I concoct, as long or short as it may be, will be woefully devoid of studious attention to detail or a coherent assessment within the context of intellectual observance. Nope. Whatever I say will flow from feeling, glimpses of feeling and slight psychological triggers based on excitement, tension and deeply held unconscious suspicions. First of all, Michael Bay is the high-end catalog photog, the Victoria's Secret photog if you will, where Michael Mann is the guy they get to do the editorial work, the
Vogue guy. Bay gets paid more, hits his money shots and fills the thing up. Mann gets paid less and concentrates on higher photographic ideals. Maybe Bay wants to be Mann. Maybe Mann wants to be Bay. Maybe, Bay wants to be Bay with Mann's photographic acumen, while Mann wants to be hanging his stuff in a gallery in Chelsea. I don't know. I just don't know. Either way, I'll always pick a Mann movie over a Bay movie. Any day of the week. Do you see what I'm getting at?
Public Enemies is not a bad film. It is a little, pretty and depressing snapshot of a moment in time when things changed. It captures, briefly, that moment affecting some characters long used to the old way of doing things. It's one of those movies. It does its job with visual aplomb. Michael Mann is a very good photographer, see. What he is not, perhaps, is a director who gets anywhere beyond photography, a director who can sustain the artifice of time passing and the emotional toll time passing inflicts. Johnny Depp is handsome and enigmatic. Marion Cotillard is beautiful and wildly effective. Christian Bale is taut and dispensable. I bet this film would work great as a graphic novel.
Inglorious Basterds, however, is an event that takes the artifice and mischievousness of cinema to its logical, regal end. Time passes. Emotions are glibly felt. There is blood and explosion and gunfire and stabbings and scenes rendered tenuous, tight with expectation. There is beauty and destruction and the destruction of beauty which is itself beautiful. It is fanciful and ingenious and a far better thing than anything Tarantino has done since
Pulp Fiction or
Reservoir Dogs. There is a moment where characters banter back and forth in quotes from WWII movies produced after WWII. Each actor inhabits their character completely. It is bizarre and stupid and completely unnecessary. This is a movie as movie for the movies. And I'll never watch it again. Forget it. That would be a waste of time.